Top 10 affordable car insurance companies for teen drivers
Finding affordable car insurance for teenage drivers can be a tough challenge. Because companies charge much higher rates to teenagers since they are statistically more likely to be involved in accidents and have less driving experience. In fact, adding a teenager to an existing policy might increase from 50% to 100%. However, with appropriate information, you may discover fair rates and valuable discounts that can lower the cost of teen drivers insurance. This detailed guide explores 10 leading car insurers offering the most affordable rates for teenage drivers. It highlights the specific discounts, innovative incentives, and personalized insurance policy plans designed to help young-age drivers. Furthermore, the guide includes practical ways that parents can use to significantly lower their insurance rates while keeping their teens fully protected on the roads.
How to select the best teen driver insurance companies?
Finding affordable car insurance for teenage drivers can be a tough challenge:
- Affordability: we calculated the annual average cost for teens on standalone policies and as part of a family.
- Discounts for teens: we highlight the companies offering significant relevant discounts for teenage drivers, such as students, driver’s education, and distant education discounts.
- Safety programs: we evaluate the quality and impact of specialized programs that encourage and promote safe driving for teen drivers.
- Customer feedback: J.D. Power, Official Complaint Indices (NAIC), and direct customer testimonials are used for customer ratings.
- Coverage options: we look for the high-quality coverage options to meet the specific requirements of teen drivers.
- Financial stability: Through ratings from agencies like AM Best to confirm the company’s financial stability to ensure the ability to pay claims.
- Technology and tools: For simple policy management, we assess the efficiency of digital services like mobile apps and online portals.
Our ultimate investigation combines the data from industry reports, and consumer’s remarks, and quotes to give a complete summary of each provider’s offer for teens and their families.
Ready to Find the Best Rate for Your Teen Driver?
Compare personalized quotes from multiple insurers to find the most affordable coverage for your teen driver.
1. GEICO: Best Overall Value for Teen Drivers
- Report the insurance provider after the accident.
- Carefully record the scene through photographs, videos, and detailed written notes about the accident.
- Use online applications such as mobile apps and online portals to start the claim process.
- Request an insurance investigator to look for the details.
- Evaluate the damage to determine the cost of repair.
- Payment for the vehicle repair and replacement.
The efficiency and client experience throughout these steps might vary significantly between the companies. Let’s look at the top 10 insurance companies and how they handle the process.
State Farm Insurance Claims Process
Overall Rating
State Farm offers affordable coverage for young drivers, with an average yearly cost roughly around $1,500 for a standalone policy. This company distinguishes itself for offering substantial student discounts and a variety of programs designed exclusively to support and insure young drivers.
Available Discounts for Teen Drivers
- Good Student Discount: Up to 25% off for students with good grades (one of the highest in the industry)
- Student Away at School Discount: Savings when your student is away at school without a car (100+ miles from home)
- Driver Training Discount: Discount for completing an approved driver education course
- Steer Clear Safe Driver Discount: Additional savings after completing State Farm's safe driving program
Unique Features for Teen Drivers
- IntelliDrive program: This is a usage-based insurance program that uses smart options to monitor driver driving behavior. Demonstrating safe driving behavior can lead to discounts.
- Reasonable driver plan: This feature offers you both accident forgiveness and minor violation forgiveness.
- Premier new car replacement: You can replace your new car with a brand-new car if the vehicle is totaled within 5 years.
Pros: Rates for teen drivers are consistently low. Multiple discount options Strong financial stability (A++ rating from AM Best) Options for comprehensive coverage
Cons: Low rating for customer service. Mixed views are shown in the mobile app. A good student discount is lower than others.
Connect with State Farm
Speak with a local agent about special discounts for your teen driver.
3. Progressive: Best for Customizable Coverage
Overall Rating
Progressive offers teen drivers an average annual premium of $1,670 for their own policies. The company stands out for its highly customizable coverage options and innovative tools that help families find the right balance of coverage and affordability.
Available Discounts for Teen Drivers
- Good Student Discount: Savings for students maintaining a B average or better
- Distant Student Discount: Reduced rates when your student is away at school without a car
- Teen Driver Discount: Special savings specifically for teen drivers
- Multi-Policy Discount: Savings when bundling auto with home, renters, or other policies
Unique Features for Teen Drivers
- Snapshot Program: Usage-based insurance that monitors driving habits and can lead to discounts for safe driving
- Name Your Price Tool: Helps families find coverage options that fit their budget
- Small Accident Forgiveness: Claims less than $500 won't increase your rate
- Deductible Savings Bank: Reduces your collision deductible by $50 for every claim-free policy period
Pros: Highly customizable coverage options Innovative tools for finding affordable coverage Multiple discount opportunities Strong digital experience with robust mobile app
Cons: No driver training discount Rates can increase significantly after claims Customer service ratings are average
Customize Your Teen's Coverage
Use Progressive's Name Your Price tool to find coverage that fits your budget.
4. USAA: Best for Military Families
Overall Rating
For teen drivers, USAA offers exceptionally affordable insurance rates with average yearly premiums of approximately $1,289 for an individual policy. This company is frequently recognized as having one of the most affordable prices for insuring teen drivers.
Available Discounts for Teen Drivers
- Good student discount: A student might receive a premium discount if they maintain a high academic record.
- Driver training discount: Teens are eligible for extra savings if they complete a certified driving training course.
- Family discount: When parents are policyholders or have USAA membership, they are rewarded with a special discount.
- Military installation discount: Cars that are parked in a military base can avail a 15% discount.
Unique Features for Teen Drivers
- SafePilot program: This usage-based insurance program can monitor driving habits, and you can get a discount for safe driving on the road.
- Military deployment vehicle storage: This offers reduced insurance rates for a vehicle that is placed in storage while a policyholder is deployed.
Pros: Lowest rates for qualified families on a regular basis Outstanding customer rating service Strong financial stability (A++ rating from AM Best) policy management through a mobile app
Cons: Limited for military families No local agent available No gap insurance option
Military Family? Check USAA Rates
See why USAA is consistently rated best for military families with teen drivers.
5. American Family: Best for Teen Safety Programs
Overall Rating
American Family offers and an average yearly premium of approximately $2,273 for a teen driver’s policy, which is higher than some other competitors. The company distinguishes itself with strong safety initiatives and particularly valuable discounts for families and students.
Available Discounts for Teen Drivers
- Good student discount: Students who maintain good grades get up to a 5% premium discount.
- Student away at school discount: A student who lives away from school and does not have any vehicle can get a discount of 16%.
- Teen safe driver program discount: Participating in this program for 1 year may result in a discount of up to a 10%.
- Young volunteer discount: This offers rewards to teen drivers who actively participate in volunteering and community services.
Unique Features for Teen Drivers
- Teen safe driver program: This program uses in-vehicle technology to track down teen drivers, driving behavior, and assist them in learning safe driving skills.
- Diminishing deductible: This feature promotes claims-free driving by automatically reducing the policy’s comprehensive and collision deductibles by $100 every year without a claim and maximizes savings up to $500.
Pros: Industry-leading teen driver safety program Huge discount for students away from school Strong local agent network Lower NAIC complaint ratio
Cons: Higher base rates compared to other competitors Only available in 19 states The good student discount is lower than competitors.
Protect Your Teen Driver
Learn more about American Family's Teen Safe Driver Program and special discounts.
6. Travelers: Best for Budget-Conscious Families
Overall Rating
Travelers offers some of the most competitive rates for teen drivers, with an average yearly premium of roughly $1,249 for an individual policy. This position the company as an affordable choice for families finding the most cost-effective coverage without sacrificing quality.
Available Discounts for Teen Drivers
- Good student discount: Students who maintain a “B” grade result can get a premium discount.
- Student away at school discount: Savings are available for students away from school without regular access to a vehicle.
- Driver training discount: Completing a driver training course can lead to a discount.
- Early quote discount: Obtaining a quote before the policy expires can result in some savings.
Unique Features for Teen Drivers
- IntelliDrive program: This is a usage-based insurance program that uses smart options to monitor driver driving behavior. Demonstrating safe driving behavior can lead to discounts.
- Reasonable driver plan: This feature offers you both accident forgiveness and minor violation forgiveness.
- Premier new car replacement: You can replace your new car with a brand-new car if the vehicle is totaled within 5 years.
Pros: Rates for teen drivers are consistently low. Multiple discount options Strong financial stability (A++ rating from AM Best) Options for comprehensive coverage
Cons: Low rating for customer service. Mixed views are shown in the mobile app. A good student discount is lower than others.
Save with Travelers
Get a quote from one of the most affordable insurers for teen drivers.
7. Nationwide: Best for Customizable Discounts
Overall Rating
Nationwide offers a wide range of discounts and a very flexible approach to coverage. It provides teen drivers an average yearly premium of $2,347 for insurance compared to other competitors.
Available Discounts for Teen Drivers
- Good student discount: Students can receive a discount of 4% if they maintain a “B” grade or above constantly
- Student away at school discount: When a student lives away from school without any access to a vehicle, they can get up to a 5% discount.
- SmartRide discount: Teen drivers can save up to 40% by safe driving habits.
- Accident-free discount: Drivers can save by keeping an accident-free record.
Unique Features for Teen Drivers
- SmartRide program: This program can monitor drivers, behavior and driving habits and can lead to discounts.
- Vanishing deductible: By automatically reducing deductibles by $100 for each year without a claim, up to a $500 reduction.
- Accident forgiveness: This feature provides protection for new drivers by not increasing the rate for the first at-fault accident.
- 24/7 Roadside assistance: Provide you 24/7 assistance with typical problems like lockouts, flat tires, and more.
Pros: Numerous chances of discount Option for highly customized coverage Strong financial stability (A++ rating from AM Best) Very low complaint ratio with NAIC
Cons: Higher base rates as compared to others The industry average is higher than the good student discount. Not accessible in Alaska, Hawaii, Louisiana, and Massachusetts
Customize Your Coverage
Explore Nationwide's customizable coverage options and discount programs.
8. Erie Insurance: Best Regional Option
Overall Rating
Erie Insurance stands out for providing some of the most affordable base rates for teen drivers, with an average yearly premium of about $1,167 for individual insurance.And because of this, Erie is ranked as the most affordable option for families in the region it serves.
Available Discounts for Teen Drivers
- Youthful driver discount: This offers a saving for unmarried drivers under 21 who live with their parents.
- Youthful longevity discount: Young drivers who have been serving Erie for years are eligible for a discount and can save some money.
- Driver training discount: Teens who successfully complete a certified driver training course can get a discount.
- Distant student discount: A full-time unmarried college student who lives away without access to a car can get a discount.
Unique Features for Teen Drivers
- Rate lock: This feature saves you against yearly rate rises by freezing your premium. Your rates only change when you add or remove a vehicle, add a new driver, or change your address.
- First accident forgiveness: Erie will not change the rates for your first at-fault accident after three years in a row.
- Diminishing deductible: Your deductibles are reduced by $100 each year for keeping a free claim record, with a maximum $500 reduction.
- New driver protection: Protect new drivers from surcharges in the event of their first at-fault accident as a new driver.
Pros: Always the lowest rates in the state where they are available Outstanding rating for customer service Unique features Strong financial stability (A++ rating from AM Best)
Cons: Limited availability only in 12 states and DC No special discount for good students No usage-based insurance policy
Check Erie Insurance Availability
See if Erie's exceptional rates and service are available in your area.
9. Allstate: Best for Educational Resources
Overall Rating
Allstate offers teen drivers coverage costing around $2,261 per year for an individual policy. Despite having base rates higher than other competitors, it distinguishes itself through a strong commitment to young drivers safety and education.
Available Discounts for Teen Drivers
- Good student discount: Students who maintain good grades are eligible for a premium discount of up to 5%.
- Student away at school discount: Save when your student lives away from school without any access to a vehicle.
- TeenSMART discount: Teens who successfully complete the TeenSMART driver education program can avail the discount.
- Drive-wise discount: This discount is based on the driving behavior, which is monitored through Allstate’s mobile app.
Unique Features for Teen Drivers
- TeenSMART program: This is an interactive driving education program designed for feedback, and to provide coaching to reduce the risk of accidents.
- Drive-wise: This is a usage-based insurance plan that monitors driving habits and safe driving through using a mobile app.
- Mile-wise: For those who can’t drive frequently, this pay-per-mile insurance plan is an affordable choice.
- Accident forgiveness: This is an optional feature that includes a policy of reducing the rates after your first accident.
Pros: Detailed resources for teen driver education Strong network of local agents for personalized service Discount opportunities Pay-per-mile options and usage-based alternatives
Cons: Higher base rates than others The industry average is higher. An above-normal complaint ratio with NAIC
Explore Allstate's Teen Programs
Learn more about Allstate's educational resources and discount programs for teen drivers.
10. Liberty Mutual: Best for Additional Coverage Options
Overall Rating
Liberty Mutual teen drivers insurance coverage costs on average around $2,560 per year for an individual policy. The company distinguishes itself by offering large selections of extra coverage alternatives and a more flexible approach to policy building.
Available Discounts for Teen Drivers
- Good student discount: Students who secure a “B” grade can get a discount.
- Student away at school discount: Savings are available for those students who live away from school without access to a car.
- Right-Track discount: Savings up to 30% on the basis of safe driving habits.
- Advance safety features discount: Vehicles featuring advance safety technology can get additional discounts.
Unique Features for Teen Drivers
- Right-Track program: This usage-based insurance option uses smart apps to monitor safe driving habits and can lead to significant discounts.
- Accident forgiveness: This is an optional feature that prevents your premium from increasing at your first at-fault accident.
- New car replacement: You can replace your totaled car with a brand one of the same make and model.
- Better car replacement: Replace your totaled vehicle with a new one that is one model year newer and has 15,000 fewer miles, offering better value.
Pros: A wide range of extra coverage options Highly customized policies Strong mobile app digital experience 24/7 roadside assistance available
Cons: Base rates are higher than other competitors. No discount for driving training Higher than average complaint ratio with NAIC
Customize Your Coverage
Explore Liberty Mutual's customizable coverage options and discount programs.
Comparison of Top 10 Auto Insurance Companies for Teen Drivers
| Insurance Company | Average Annual Premium for Teens | Good Student Discount | Student Away Discount | Driver Training Discount | Usage-Based Program | Accident Forgiveness |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| GEICO | $1,355 | Up to 15% | No | Yes | DriveEasy | |
| State Farm | $1,500 | Up to 25% | Yes | Yes | Drive Safe & Save | |
| Progressive | $1,670 | Yes | Yes | No | Snapshot | |
| USAA | $1,289 | Yes | No | Yes | SafePilot | |
| American Family | $2,273 | Up to 5% | Up to 16% | Yes | KnowYourDrive | |
| Travelers | $1,249 | Yes | Yes | Yes | IntelliDrive | |
| Nationwide | $2,347 | Up to 4% | Up to 5% | No | SmartRide | |
| Erie | $1,167 | No | Yes | Yes | No | |
| Allstate | $2,261 | Up to 5% | Yes | No | Drivewise | |
| Liberty Mutual | $2,560 | Yes | Yes | No | RightTrack |
Tips for Parents to Reduce Teen Car Insurance Premiums
It is important to note that the costs are based on the average annual premium for teen drivers who carry their own insurance. It highlights that the actual price any individual pays will vary based on the number of circumstances, like location, vehicle type, and others. Not all discounts are available everywhere.
1. Shop Around and Compare Quotes
To obtain the most affordable rate, it’s important to compare quotes from various insurance providers. Price for the same coverage might vary dramatically, so searching around is the most effective way to find a good discount. You can use online tools to make work easier and faster.
2. Keep Your Teen on Your Policy
Instead of purchasing your teen their own insurance, you may save money by adding them to your current coverage. This allows you to benefit from various discounts and capitalize on your good driving history.
3. Choose the Right Vehicle
Selecting the appropriate vehicle for your teen might result in a big savings in insurance rates. Consider a car with high safety ratings and up-to-date features, instead of a luxury or sports car, as they often qualify for cheaper prices and savings.
4. Assign Your Teen to the Least Expensive Car
If you have many vehicles, make your teen the primary driver of the least costly car to insure. This is usually an older and safer model with low repair costs.
5. Maximize Available Discounts
Make sure to ask about available discounts like good student grades, students away at school, and driver training courses. Some companies also offer discounts on vehicles for safety features.
6. Consider Usage-Based Insurance
Many companies consider usage-based insurance programs like telematics. This program helps in monitoring driving behavior and safe driving through mobile apps and devices. This program is beneficial for teen drivers as they get rewards.
7. Increase Deductibles
You can reduce your rates by opting for higher deductibles. However, you have to make sure you have enough savings to cover the high deductible amount in case of accident.
8. Maintain Good Grades
Many insurance companies offer discounts for students who secure good grades and save up to 25%.
Important: While it's tempting to reduce coverage to save money, maintaining adequate liability coverage is crucial. Teen drivers are statistically more likely to be involved in accidents, so having appropriate coverage protects your family's assets in case of a serious accident.
Ready to Find Affordable Coverage for Your Teen?
Compare personalized quotes from top insurers to find the best rate for your family.
Frequently Asked Questions About Teen Car Insurance
At what age does car insurance go down for young drivers?
Car insurance rates typically decrease when teens reach the age of 25, assuming they have a clean driving record. However, you may see reduction at the age of 21. Rates start reducing with each year of safe driving experiences. Some insurance companies provide a premium a reduction to teen drivers at the ages of 19 and 20, or after three years of safe driving without any accidents.
Why is car insurance so expensive for teen drivers?
Insurance companies charge high a premium for teen drivers, as studies suggest that they are more likely to be involved in accidents. According to the Insurance Institute of Highway Safety, the accident rate per mile driven among 16-19-year-olds is around three times that of drivers aged 20 or older. Teens who lack driving skills are more likely to be involved in unsafe driving, as they use phones while driving and are easily distracted. These qualities make them a higher risk for custom
Should my teen have their own policy or be added to mine?
For most families, adding a teen driver to their existing coverage is more beneficial and less expensive than purchasing a separate one. This allows the kid to take advantage of their parent’s driving history as well as discounts on multiple policy factors. Separate coverage is only recommended if the parent has a poor driving record or if the teen buys their own vehicle.
What coverage do teen drivers need?
Teen drivers should have at least the minimum liability coverage required by their state. However, since teens are more likely to be involved in accidents, it is generally advised that you purchase higher liability coverage to protect your assets in the event of serious damage. If your teen is newer and has an expensive car, comprehensive and collision coverage is necessary. Other coverage includes: Uninsured or underinsured car coverage Medical cost or personal injury coverage Roadside assistance Rental vehicle compensation
What are the best cars for teen drivers from an insurance perspective?
Teens, most insurance-friendly vehicles are mid-sized sedans and compact SUVs that have strong safety ratings, dependability, and low maintenance costs. Avoid high-performance sports cars and high-priced SUVs. Some examples of vehicles for teens that have lower insurance costs: Honda Civic Toyota Corolla Mazda 3 Subaru Impreza Hyundai Elantra
How can telematics or usage-based insurance help teen drivers?
Telematics systems can track driving via mobile apps or plug-in devices and assist teen drivers in two key ways: they provide significant discounts for safe driving and provide valuable feedback to help them to build better habits. These programs monitor actions like driving behavior, safe driving, speeding, and phone use, and turn safe driving into rewards.
Conclusion: finding the right insurance coverage
With an appropriate strategy, you can get inexpensive teen car insurance. Start by comparing quotes of different insurance companies. Companies including GEICO, State Farm, Travelers, and many more can provide you beneficial discounts and services for your teen drivers. Take advantage of available discounts and look for usage-based insurance programs that encourage safe driving. Remember, the cheapest coverage isn’t best if it leaves your teen underinsured. The best investment is in appropriate coverage, which results in a cheaper premium as your teen builds a safe driving record.
Start Saving on Teen Car Insurance Today
Compare personalized quotes from top insurers to find affordable coverage for your teen driver.
